Talk:Demigirlflux

Several Things
1) In responce to your comment "Demigirlflux is NOT a feminine gender identity. Are you claiming that someone who is AMAB who identifies with this is feminine?" Yes, I am claiming that. Saying that an AMAB person cannot be a feminine gender is horribly transphobic. Furthermore: It is a combination of two feminine genders. Demigender is partly female and it therefore feminine. Girlflux is when the amount of femininity you expirence flucutates. It is therefore feminine the majority of the time and is defined by it's femininity. A combination of the two of them would be, by definition, feminine.

2) The current definition makes no sense. The statements "Girlflux is when one's femininity is fluid, but never enough to make feel fully like a male." and "but at the most feminine, they feel like a demigirl, and one's most masculine, they feel like a demiboy. " seem to imply that if someone is not feminine then they are, by default, masculine, which isn't true. If someone is girlflux then the amount of femininity expirenced changes. Sometimes they are strongly feminine, sometimes they are weakly feminine. A genderflux person's gender is not fluid, the intensity of their gender becomes stronger or weaker. (A girlflux might also feel masculine genders but that is not a requirement, and those masculine genders would be unrelated to their girlflux identity.) What you are describing, where one's gender is fluid, might be better described as demifluid with a preference for femininity.

3) Also, I can't find Vampiirekid's explaination of demigirlflux.

Chaoticcylinder (talk) 22:33, July 11, 2020 (UTC)